Underdog

811 reviews

55 Stone St, New York, NY 10004

www.underdogbarnyc.com

+19174090251

About

Underdog is a Bar located at 55 Stone St, New York, NY 10004. It has received 811 reviews with an average rating of 4.3 stars.

Photos

Hours

Monday12PM-2AM
Tuesday12PM-4AM
Wednesday12PM-4AM
Thursday12PM-12AM
Friday12PM-12AM
Saturday12PM-2AM
Sunday12PM-2AM

F.A.Q

Frequently Asked Questions

  • The address of Underdog: 55 Stone St, New York, NY 10004

  • Underdog has 4.3 stars from 811 reviews

  • Bar

  • "The Underdog was a nice place to have a dinner on the blocked street patio environment"

    "Best bar in the fidi hands down"

    "The service was awesome, waiter girl was very friendly and quick (5/5)"

    "Great bar for afterwork crowd, meetup with friends etc"

    "Nice place a good appetizers"

Reviews

  • Ben Pol

The Underdog was a nice place to have a dinner on the blocked street patio environment. Very reasonable prices and fries were included with the burger which is uncommon in almost NYC restaurants. The burger was fantastic and the fries were really good as well. Nice beer and atmosphere. Will recommend to everyone. More

  • anan afridi

Best bar in the fidi hands down. Matthew is amazing. Makes soothing drinks and a fun guy to talk with. Marko and Javier is great alongside Alison. Overall I'll definitely recommend people to take a look at this place. The food and drinks and the music won't disappoint you. It's a vibe you don't wanna miss out on

  • David Chitanava

The service was awesome, waiter girl was very friendly and quick (5/5). Drinks were also fine (4/5). However, the food was absolutely terrible (1/5). I was surprised how they managed to put so many ingredients in a sandwich and make it tasteless. They definitely need to pay more attention to the kitchen.

  • Adam M

Great bar for afterwork crowd, meetup with friends etc. most everyone is coming from after work. Friendly atmosphere, bartenders are great, can get packed. Drinks are reasonable and well made. Crowded but always room to scoot in and find you or your groups section standing or being seated. Recommend.

  • T P

Nice place a good appetizers. Would have preferred the female bartender tone down her conversation and her language. She talked over the music—and the conversation at our table— the entire time. Nice place, but our entire party was glad to get away from that annoyance.

  • Cindy Vermont

We had the best experience. Angel was our waiter and he was so friendly, funny and made us feel at home. He gave us the best directions to the subway. I LOVED the vegan cauliflower Buffalo wings and the vegan sliders. My girls had a BLT and

  • Javier Castellote

I like the place for what it is, a nice pub to meet friends . However, considering it costs 18$ the burger, it could be Bigger, Better and the fries could be cooked close to the moment when they are served rather than fried again or heated

  • Aleksandr Flom

We came off Governors Island ferry after a few drinks there and decided to find a place to grab a bite. We chose Underdog totally at random via Google maps. There is a lot of different places right on the same block downtown, and we had to

  • Jason Hirschfeld

Amazing Whisky bar and super friendly service. I was waiting for my hotel room and this bar was a great place to pass the time with a snack and a drink. The buffalo cauliflower was delicious and I tried dovetail whisky which was new to me

  • Ron Epstein

Great little hole-in-the-wall restaurant on Stone street with fairly inexpensive eats that were quite good. Great place for a sandwich and beer. I had the Cubano sandwich with fries and really enjoyed it. The host was extremely welcoming.

  • Claudia Riera

The service was beyond amazing! Our server Javier was supper attentive with us the moment we sat down! We had just gone to another restaurant down the street from them and waited for 10 minutes and no one came to us, so we left and found

  • Joe Costa

Food was meh, but the short chubby dimwitted short haired blonde waiting us was as rude as they come. She got all annoyed with me for pointing out she overcharged me and then proceeded to mock me when I asked for the card machine to pay.

  • Maria Bustamante-Abad

We went to the downstairs area and it was really beautiful. Loved the decor and lighting. Food and cocktail menu seemd great, we ordered the fried pickles that also included other fried vegetables and we were there for it. It was really

  • Hee Jeong Kim

Went there for happy hour with coworkers. I really liked the bar and the vibe. It was too crowded so the servers were often not available. Both my coworker and I found this pink spots on chicken so we called the server. Immediately, the

  • Madrid Vinarski

Stopped in because we were in the area and heard they had some options for vegans / vegetarians and was pleasantly surprised by the amount of options and the quality of the food. For a place that isn’t dedicated to vegan food, they put

  • Kat Stevens

Cool place and vibes. Food was extremely average and service below average. One person working and lots of people. The singular staff member was quite condescending and unhelpful tbh. Wouldn’t recommend and overpriced - sorry !

  • happy x

The best bar on Stone St! The staff have always gone above awesome even with, e.g., starting multiple private phone screen sports games screenings, being great and accommodating to be around, the hottest crowd ever for events!

  • Ameya Bhakay

Me and friend went here on a rainy Friday and the place wasn't that busy in the afternoon. We ordered a few lagers and got their Impossible burger sliders which were really filling and excellent to share between 2 people.

  • Y R

It's hard not to mention great service and delicious burgers. I personally recommend to get Cosa Nostra burger with arancini patties. I've tried it for the first time and what a combination. I like to experiment and try

  • John Spears

Loved the shared outdoor patio on thr Street. The bar has a great vibe too. Staff was awesome and put up with beer tourist asking questions. Would have liked a little more selection on beer, but otherwise it was great.

  • Shawn Borich Hernandez

Great place. Love the music. The food is all great. The impossible sliders taste better than most burgers. The cauliflower wings are worth going alone. Good selection of beers and well crafted cocktails.

  • Charles Cordova

Serves the Impossible burger, all vegan which is a necessary component for me Tremendous craft beer selection, courteous service and located on the venerable Stone Street in FiDi Highly recommended

  • Gabriela Vergara

Loved the dogs in a blanket Miss NYC Normal, but really appreciate how restaurants are doing their best to keep everyone happy! Our food was delicious and everyone was kind …

  • Chris

Good drinks, good food. They have Focal Banger so I was hooked from the beginning. Korean Fries (bulgogi and kimchi over fries) were ok, the fried pickles were better. Friendly staff.

  • Eric Finkelstein

I'm rating 5 stars for listing the beer menu on Untappd to easily find what's highly rated - - the Hudson Valley "Ultrasphere" sour IPA was one of my favorite beers ever.

  • Neal Patel

Overpriced compared to back in the day :( decently diverse food selection and nice happy hour spot for a group. A bit dark inside, but it's part of a great aesthetic More

  • Tristan Carrieri

Drinks were solid, location is good. Music was too loud though, could barely have a conversation with the person sitting next to me without needing to yell More

  • Ekaterina Smirnova

We ordered burgers and wings. Fast service, friendly staff, fresh and tasty food. There are tables outside. But we were inside. Our temperature were checked.

  • Magna Gopal

Loud bar which tends to be crowded. If you can manage to get a seat, they've got a solid menu! The bone marrow dish and the pork belly sliders were delish!

  • Kayvin Robertson

Great little bar for a cocktail or quick bite. Had a few drinks and good conversation with our bartender. Would return and try some of the seasonal drinks.

  • Manny Success

One of my favorite bars to go to in the Financial district. The bartenders are friendly and attentive. The food is delicious and so are the drinks.

  • Martin Utreras

Great bar food! We went on a weekday and it wasn't too busy. The servers were super nice and the beer on tap was great. I recommend the dogfish IPA.

  • Byron Banger

Great value and good variety on the menu. Service could be better, had to find the waiter talking to mates at the bar to get service, twice. More

  • Angel Columbus

This is it folks, Lots of beer options and tasty Menu. I think they price the menu accordingly, they have cool bartenders but sometimes

  • Anna Długołęcka

More than great! The food was delicious (recommended burger dog) and drinks f.e.devil dog good climate worth to go! …

  • Victor C

Excellent bar food, good cocktails and beer selection. Wings, one of the best. They split the sections so they are easy to eat and

  • Evelyn Morales

Great spot to meet up with friends! Good vibe...service was very attentive and friendly!
Price per pe…
More

  • Melissa O'Connor

Great place to go as a vegetarian! It was awesome to have a selection of regular bar food in vegetarian style.

  • Michael William Majorczak

Great Pub. Excellent service. Great Beer Selection and Food Menu. My burger was perfect. Great atmosphere.

  • Tran D

We rented out the space for a holiday party! They had great drinks and appetizers ❤️ very accommodating.

  • Mahima Srivastava

Cool bar on stone street. We had couple of beers on tap and I tried devil dog cocktail too. Delicious.

  • joHN CARRAS

I like this place however I think we were overcharged for our drinks.
Price per person…
More

  • Gianni Cavicchi

The crispy sandwich is truly special. Get it with the spicy aioli. Service is fantastic

  • Andy Cardinaels

Great bar, good drinks (which are a bit on the expensive side). nice place overall.

  • Karl König-Mehrtüssen

Loved this place. Food was so tasty. It's just a pity they don't split the bill.

  • Mike Wong

Mango habanero wings are pretty good.
Price per person
$50–100…
More

  • Ric Castillo

Low-key spot in FiDi to get your drink on with a nice dash of personality.

  • Mari

Good drinks, the fiddlehead IPA was great. Fast and friendly service.

  • Keiron Ramoutar

Really great bar. Great cocktails and service.
Food: 5…
More

  • Shankar Kulumani

Great space to stop for a drink. BBQ Cauliflower was very good

Similar places

Fraunces Tavern

4847 reviews

54 Pearl St, New York, NY 10004

Rudy's Bar & Grill

4376 reviews

627 9th Ave, New York, NY 10036

Harlem Public

2037 reviews

3612 Broadway, New York, NY 10031

Watermark

1981 reviews

78 South St Pier 15, New York, NY 10038

Whiskey Tavern

1814 reviews

79 Baxter St A, New York, NY 10013

Chili's Grill & Bar

1423 reviews

1497 Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY 10314

Phebe's

1260 reviews

361 Bowery, New York, NY 10003

Sweet Science

1258 reviews

135 Graham Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11206

Dive Bar

1241 reviews

732 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025

Lee's Tavern

1240 reviews

60 Hancock St, Staten Island, NY 10305