Scott is, by far, the most compotenent, well informed, kind, and thorough jeweler I've ever dealt with. And above all else, he is fair. I would, WILL, recommend him to any and all persons looking to buy or sell their jewelery. Or anyone even looking to learn about wjatbtheybthink they possess. 10 out of 10 on my book.

Great service. Honest people. Prices are very competitive, regardless of what service you need. We got assistance with another area of our lives that was completely off topic as to our visit, and desperately needed. Just really good, helpful people. I'm sold. This is going to be my go-to jeweler forever now.

I have personally known Scott, the owner for many years. He has always been straight and honest even if he isn't particularly interested in my merchandise. I have bought most of my jewelry from him and always gotten fair pricing and service. I highly recommend him for your jewelry needs.

Ive been here a handful of times but everytime I leave I am very happy with the service and products and my wife loves the jewelry I have purchased for her from there,just dont tell her my secret spot lol Jk.,but Id suggest this place to anyone needing a reputable jeweler.

I had such a great, personable experience with the owner. He was very nice and friendly. I loved the items that I purchased from here. Also, whatever he didn’t have that I had in mind, he ordered it and gave me a discount. I would highly recommend him!

He was very helpful in time of need to sell a ring. Month's later I wanted to see if I could buy it back. He didn't have to look around for it but he took the time to find it and I bought back at a fare price. I was so happy. Thanks so much.

Found this New York style Jeweler that you would expect around Rockerfeller Center in New York City. What a Gem he is. I've purchased jewelry, had pieces repaired, cleaned, and have been educated on the appreciated value of my pieces. He

My husband and I visited today and the shop was closed. Neon sign was on and said open but there was a sign on the door saying “Be right back”. After waiting a half hour we called both numbers available and we were told someone would be

New Owner is Scott O'Harra. He sells all sorts of jewelry from retro to vintage grandma to semi-precious to ultra-precious. Will design what you want. Sells loose stones of various sorts. He is also a beader and works with real stone

The only jewelry store i go to weather im selling or buying. The owner is down to earth and very informative. Very fair prices. Very helpful. If you want a good deal and a jeweler that knows his stuff go to American Jeweler.

Went in to get a watch sized. Great and quick work. Talked about other pieces and stuff he had in his store. A little bit of everything for everyone. Very knowledgeable and will definitely be back. Would recommend to anyone.

The guy was super friendly and helpful, he has really unique and very pretty jewelry inside. I had a very small pendant that I no longer had a use for and he gave me a very fair price! Definitely worth the stop!

Went in to have a link in a watch bracelet removed, best service Ive ever had. Turns out hes a famous artist and designer. Great service and prices. I spent 500 dollars in there.

By far the best place in town to go!! They are honest and so so nice, they go outta their way to help you. And want the customer to be happy. And the prices are amazing!

The owner is very friendly and nice to people. He. Is very helpful. He is very kind also.he also helps his people that comes in his shop also. He has great prices also.

Scott was very helpful. I got exactly what I was looking for and I got a great deal. I'm super happy and this will be my first stop on my next purchase! Thanks Scott

Walked in to sell a ring and got a lot more than I thought I would. So very easy to deal with and above fair on price. He will get all my business from now on !!!

Everybody thinks he's ok guy. He's not. I come to buy jewelry, not to here his life story. also your a business man,you suppose to keep your appearence up.

Scott is a really nice guy, he tries to help out the best he can. I would recommend him to anyone looking for anything jewelry related. Thanks Scott!

Owner is friendly and very honest prices are great,my wife purchased my wedding band for me a very reasonable price for a good quality ring

Great selection of jewelry art and ect. Over is a pleasure to interact with and does repairs and custom made jewelry a real Indiana treat.

By far my favorite store !!! !!! ! Each piece American Jeweler seems to have is of astounding quality and uniquely one of a kind.

Scott was very informative, helpful, and friendly! There looked to be a really great selection of jewelry to buy here, as well.

Really good, caring people. He'll give it to you straight and help you out. Have a custom piece created here!

The guy that runs this place is awesome he's honest he don't try to rip you off it's the only place I go now

Best secret in town. Fast friendly and honest. This is my go to for all my blingy bling! Scott rocks!!!

Great honest jeweler. Quality and price are amazing!! Got a 25 yr diamond wrap and I love it!

DONT shop here. Owner is extremely rude. take your money elsewhere!

Thank you Scott for helping me! My jewelry looks beautiful.

Scott was incredible. Top notch